Don’t Fight The Fed

John Leiper – Head of Portfolio Management – 26th May 2020

Over the last decade, the Fed has increasingly resorted to unconventional monetary policy, such as quantitative easing, or QE, to stimulate the economy.

In short, QE is where the Fed buys bonds to inject newly created money into the system to stimulate the economy.

This has happened 4 times previously, as represented by the grey bars in the chart below. We are currently in the fifth iteration of QE.

During these periods, and despite the Fed actively purchasing government bonds, prices have fallen. This is shown by the blue line, which represents the year-on-year change in the 10-year US Treasury yield. When yields rise, prices fall.

At first that might sound counterintuitive. However, it makes sense when you consider the main aim of QE is to stabilise the economy, increase growth and reflate inflation expectations, all of which are negative for bonds. Specifically, QE increases the supply of US dollars, thereby increasing liquidity, risk sentiment and risk assets, resulting in higher government bond yields. This mechanism is covered in more detail here and here.

As shown in the chart, there is a clear correlation between the movement in the 10-year US Treasury yield, in blue, and the pink line.

The pink line represents the difference between Fed purchases of government bonds (QE) and US Treasury issuance (of government bonds). When the pink line goes up, the Fed is increasing purchases relative to US Treasury issuance and bond yields rise. When the pink line goes down the Fed is reducing bond purchases relative to US Treasury issuance and bond yields fall.

On mobile: review chart in landscape mode

At least that was the narrative for QE 1-4….

The big difference this time around is the coronavirus and the sudden and dramatic devastation it has inflicted on the economy. Government rescue programs will necessitate trillions of dollars’ worth of funding. To pay for this the US Treasury is ramping-up bond issuance. In early May the Treasury announced it would need to borrow $3 trillion by the end of June which is three times the amount it borrowed for the full 2019 fiscal year. That is a huge sum of money and the final full-year figure will likely be much higher.  

The current market consensus is that the huge stimulus measures announced by the US government and the surge in liquidity unleashed by the Fed is sufficient to solve the problems facing the US. This is reflected in the strong recovery in US equity prices, up over 30% since the March bottom. However, in a scenario where the recovery is not V-shaped, and the economic damage caused by the coronavirus proves long-lasting, resulting in widespread corporate insolvency, then this could prove wishful thinking.

Contributing to the problem is the fact this perception of a surge in liquidity, which is bullish risk assets, could prove to be a mirage. This is because the sheer scale of pending US Treasury issuance could overwhelm Fed bond purchases going forward. Anecdotally, Fed bond purchases have already fallen from $75 billion per day, at the height of the crisis, to $6 billion per day this week even as US Treasury issuance ramps-up. If the Treasury issues more bonds than the Fed buys, this could drain liquidity, and US dollars, from the system, hurting risk sentiment and resulting in a fall in the dotted pink line, alongside US Treasury yields (and global equity markets).

 

A different perspective is that the resulting surplus of bonds could see bond yields rise…

A different perspective is that the resulting surplus of bonds could see bond yields rise, as the absence of the Fed (as buyer of last resort) reduces market confidence, and purchases in the private sector, and the sheer scale of debt brings the credibility of the US government into question. However, the Fed could not countenance such an outcome as it is important investors retain faith in the US financial system and its ability to repay debt. Further, the US remains the ‘cleanest dirty shirt’ in the laundry basket and the positive yield on offer, given low FX hedging costs, continues to attract demand for US debt which is backed by the “full faith and credit of the US government”. This is evident from last week’s 20-year bond auction, the first since 1986, which attracted bids in excess of $50 billion versus $20 billion available.    

The alternative scenario is one in which the dotted pink line continues to rise and the Fed increases purchases relative to the significant increase in US Treasury issuance. This is likely because the Fed has thrown away the rule book and shown it is willing to do whatever it takes to support the economy. This now includes back-stopping almost every investment vehicle going including investment grade debt, high yield bonds and “Main Street” via loans to businesses. The only thing the Fed is not buying, yet, is equity and even that remains an outside possibility (they already do it in Japan). There is now almost no distinction between the Fed and the Treasury. The credibility of the central bank (already questionable) is now under threat and there will be long-term consequences to these developments, namely inflation, which is bearish government bonds.

Multiple factors affect the US Treasury bond market, not least of which is the ongoing development of the coronavirus, the hunt for a vaccine and the economic recovery to come and whether that recovery is V, U or L shaped. Another big question mark concerns the clear inflationary consequences of both the coronavirus and the policy response to it, and the extent and timeline over which these forces emerge, against broader and more structural disinflationary headwinds. This will be the subject of a future blog.

For now, we are broadly neutral US government bonds. However, over the medium term we think the dotted pink line will rise and as such we are positioned for higher long-dated US Treasury yields. We are already seeing this play out via a steepening of the yield curve as shown in the second chart below. As always, we continue to monitor the situation, our assumptions and portfolio positioning.  

On mobile: review chart in landscape mode

This investment Blog is published and provided for informational purposes only. The information in the Blog constitutes the author’s own opinions. None of the information contained in the Blog constitutes a recommendation that any particular investment strategy is suitable for any specific person. Source of data: Bloomberg, Tavistock Wealth Limited unless otherwise stated.  

Want to know more about the Equity Markets?

Please contact us here:

4 + 13 =

Recent blogs
The high cost of cashing out

The high cost of cashing out

We are dealing with a lot at the minute; an international war, extreme market volatility, an ever-changing government and a mental health crisis. The current economic outlook is causing even the most experienced investors to re-evaluate things. A question we are often asked is what should I do? Do I sell up now and move to cash? Especially with interest rates on the rise?

read more
Quarterly Perspective 2022 Q4

Quarterly Perspective 2022 Q4

On an absolute basis the ACUMEN Portfolios have fallen in value since the start of the year. This is unsurprising given recent developments. However, on a relative basis the funds have held up well, particularly at the higher end of the risk spectrum and in the ACUMEN Income Portfolio versus the IA sector peer group against which we measure performance. On a 5-year basis, and since inception, the funds continue to perform well on both an absolute and relative basis.

read more
Should I stick or twist in a volatile market?

Should I stick or twist in a volatile market?

We are dealing with a lot at the minute; an international war, extreme market volatility, an ever-changing government and a mental health crisis. The current economic outlook is causing even the most experienced investors to re-evaluate things. A question we are often asked is what should I do? Do I sell up now and move to cash? Especially with interest rates on the rise?

read more
RECESSION, INFLATION AND RISING INTEREST RATES

RECESSION, INFLATION AND RISING INTEREST RATES

With the Bank of England announcing the biggest interest rate hike in 27 years and forecasting that Britain will enter a year-long recession with inflation topping 13%, you could be forgiven for feeling a little gloomy about things. Granted, the picture that was painted at the last Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meeting isn’t a pretty one.

read more
ROTATIONS & DIVIDENDS

ROTATIONS & DIVIDENDS

Back in November 2020 I wrote a blog, Nothing Is More Powerful Than An Idea Whose Time Has Come, in which I made the case for a Great Rotation across equity markets where the prior winners, growth stocks, would give way to value stocks which would outperform going forward.

read more
What we learn from history…

What we learn from history…

Market crashes and economic downturns are a part of life. Market calamity can occur seemingly out of nowhere and whether it be a dotcom bubble, a financial crisis, Brexit or Covid-19, we can never predict the full impact of a new market crash. We can however forecast that its effect on the markets, and the wider economy, will ultimately be temporary.

read more
MARKET THOUGHTS

MARKET THOUGHTS

In late February, following the invasion of Ukraine and subsequent market sell off, I wrote a blog (Commentary & Positioning) outlining Tavistock Asset Management’s thoughts. Three months on, financial markets have continued to come under pressure and have weakened further.

read more
RUSSIA TRADE

RUSSIA TRADE

I want to begin this blog by firstly taking time to explain why foreign exchange is an important part of portfolio composition and why as investors you should be paying close attention to currency exposure, as it could be driving or eroding your investment returns.

read more
TIP OF THE ICEBERG

TIP OF THE ICEBERG

I want to begin this blog by firstly taking time to explain why foreign exchange is an important part of portfolio composition and why as investors you should be paying close attention to currency exposure, as it could be driving or eroding your investment returns.

read more
The Commodity Carve-Out

The Commodity Carve-Out

Global markets in 2022 have exhibited abnormal volatility. Inflation readings sit at multiples of central bank targets around the world, and a plethora of rate hiking cycles have begun in attempts to combat this. Muted capital expenditure during the pandemic has left supply chains in tatters, and producers scrambling to secure inputs. When compounded by an invasion involving two hegemonic commodity producers and a pilgrimage towards net-zero carbon emissions, we at Titan believed an environment for sustained commodity outperformance was firmly in place.

read more
Importance of Foreign Exchange

Importance of Foreign Exchange

I want to begin this blog by firstly taking time to explain why foreign exchange is an important part of portfolio composition and why as investors you should be paying close attention to currency exposure, as it could be driving or eroding your investment returns.

read more
COP26 Revisited

COP26 Revisited

COP26 RevisitedWritten by James Peel - ESG Portfolio Manager - Titan Asset ManagementCOP stands for ‘Conference of the Parties’ and is the decision-making body of the United Nations Framework...

read more

Bubbles and Dividends

Bubbles and DividendsWritten by Steve McGregorAs I wrote in late January, it has been a volatile start to 2022. For the last couple of years, markets have enjoyed central banks pumping lots of money...

read more
Quarterly Perspectives 2021 Q4

Quarterly Perspectives 2021 Q4

Tavistock Asset Management Investment OutlookQuarter 4 2021 Written by Titan Asset Management Investment TeamQ4-2021 QUARTERLY PERSPECTIVESWelcome to the Q4-2021 ‘Quarterly Perspectives’...

read more
Rise of the Underdog

Rise of the Underdog

In its latest economic outlook, the OECD increased its expectations for global GDP. For 2020, the improvement is minimal, reflecting an upward revision, in real GDP, from -4.5% to -4.2%. But beyond that, growing economic momentum should boost global growth to pre-pandemic levels, estimated at 4.2% in 2021 and 3.7% in 2022.

read more
Anatomy of an Election (So far…)

Anatomy of an Election (So far…)

The narrative, heading into the US election, was a ‘Blue Wave’ victory for the Democrats. Polls and betting odds favoured a Biden win and a Senate majority and investors positioned accordingly.

read more
Since the Market Low

Since the Market Low

The ACUMEN Portfolios continued their strong run throughout October, largely outperforming the market composite benchmark and IA sectors (used for peer group comparison purposes) which lost ground across the board.

read more
The Call-Up

The Call-Up

Last week the FTSE Russell decided to include Chinese government bonds in its flagship World Government Bond Index (WGBI). The decision follows similar moves, from JP Morgan and Bloomberg, and a failed attempt to do so just one year prior which resulted in a number of reforms, to increase accessibility and currency trading options, that ultimately paved the way for benchmark admission.

read more
Technical Perspectives

Technical Perspectives

In last week’s blog we discussed the ‘Nasdaq whale’, Softbank, and the role it played, alongside an army of retail investors, driving tech prices ever higher prior to the recent correction. These short-term ‘technical’ flows are driven by the options market as traders look to hedge their underlying exposure, amplifying moves both lower and higher.

read more
A Speech For The History Books

A Speech For The History Books

In a speech for the history books, last week Fed chairman Jerome Powell announced a significant change to the way it conducts monetary policy by formally announcing ‘average inflation targeting’. This means the Fed will now allow inflation to overshoot its official 2% target to compensate for prior years where inflation failed to reach that level.

read more
Room to Run

Room to Run

Despite the fact the coronavirus has plunged many countries into recession, global equity markets are now back at all-time highs, as measured by the Bloomberg World Exchange Market Capitalisation index.

read more
Rising Phoenix

Rising Phoenix

In The Return Of Inflation (5th June 2020) we made the case for a transition from the existing deflationary narrative to one in which markets start to price-in inflation.

read more
All That Glitters…

All That Glitters…

In last week’s blog, This Time It’s Different (24 July 2020), I suggested the US dollar was on the cusp of crashing through its decade-long uptrend.

read more
The Return of Inflation

The Return of Inflation

Quantitative easing, or QE, is where a central bank creates money to buy bonds. The goal is to keep interest rates low and to stimulate the economy during periods of economic stress.

read more
The Powell Pivot 2.0

The Powell Pivot 2.0

In January 2019 Jerome Powell pivoted from a policy of interest rate increases and balance sheet cuts to interest rate cuts and, later that year, balance sheet expansion.

read more
Super Contango

Super Contango

In an unprecedented day in the history of oil trading the price of the front month contract for West Texas Intermediate (WTI) oil fell below zero to -$37.63.

read more
The beginning of the end?

The beginning of the end?

The coronavirus has brought economic activity to a virtual stand-still and transformed a strong global economy, with lots of debt, to a weak economy… with lots of debt.

read more
TAM IFA Hub